Drawing on his experience as a health minister and chair of the Health and Social Care Select Committee, GK’s strategic advisor Steve Brine examines what the abolition of NHS England means for independent providers, commercial partners and the government’s ambitions to improve patient care
I’ve described the government’s decision to abolish NHS England as ‘a huge roll of the dice’. Nothing we’ve heard since has made me more confident that the gamble will pay off.
The latest announcement that a new ‘Special Health Authority’ will accommodate NHS England’s seven regional teams is a sensible solution to a problem, and let’s be clear, that the government has created for itself.
The writers of ‘Yes Minister!’ would be proud of abolishing a quango only to find the creation of another quango carrying out some of the functions of the previous quango that is being abolished.
There is, however, a more consequential question beyond the machinery of government change: what does this mean for the organisations, including those in the independent sector, who work with the NHS to deliver care, technology, innovation and better outcomes for patients?
For companies accustomed to engaging NHS England nationally, the transfer of functions into the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) raises immediate questions about relationships, decision-making and accountability. Who will commission, approve, procure and ultimately champion innovation? Will a more politically accountable centre become a more accessible one, or simply a more cautious and centralised one?
The regional picture is more complicated in my opinion. NHS England’s regional teams have played important roles in overseeing performance, service planning and important relationships with providers. Their transition into a new body, without a clearly defined end date, leaves businesses navigating an uncertain landscape alongside ICBs whose own future responsibilities remain unresolved.
For independent providers and commercial partners, clarity matters above all else. Investment decisions can’t simply be put on hold while Whitehall redraws its spider diagram. Nor can the NHS afford to lose the capacity, expertise and innovation that external partners bring to a system under extraordinary pressure.
Having served as a health minister, and subsequently chaired the House of Commons Health and Social Care Committee, I know that changing structures is considerably easier than changing outcomes. You cannot reorganise your way out of a productivity problem and that’s one reason I wouldn’t have touched NHS reorganisation with a barge-pole post 2024.
My hunch is that Andy Burnham understands this better than most. He’s been prepared to put local government reorganisation into the long grass yet the NHS is being asked to undertake precisely the kind of structural upheaval that will sap the very energy needed for delivery.
This government likes to talk in ‘ten year plans’ but it’s landed itself with an NHS sized headache precisely because the NHS England decision was not part of a strategy for delivery in this part of the public sector voters cherish so much. If it was, abolition would have been central – and announced within – the NHS Ten Year Plan not something out of the blue that preceded it.
All said, there is an opportunity here. A smaller, clearer centre and genuinely empowered local systems could make the NHS a better partner for the independent sector, accelerating innovation and supporting care closer to home; all key planks of the decade long plan for health. But that will only happen if responsibility, budgets and decision-making follow.
If the government want to rewire the state, it should start with the connections between services that patients actually use, rather than the wiring diagram in Whitehall.
Ultimately, patients won’t judge Andy Burnham on the structures he abolishes; whether he wants them gone or not. They’ll judge him on whether the NHS works better. So should we.